Published by Emerging Technologies Laboratory · via ETL Newswire
US· 

Senate GOP Chair Kills Vote on Trump's NSF Nominee, Citing Failure to 'Stand Up for Science'

Sen. Bill Cassidy canceled a Nov. 18 committee vote on Jim O'Neill's nomination to lead the National Science Foundation, saying O'Neill lacked the support to advance and had not defended scientific integrity at HHS and the CDC.

By Marcus Reyes, Senior Correspondent · US Desk

WASHINGTON -- Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee Chairman Bill Cassidy, R-La., on Wednesday abruptly canceled a committee vote on Jim O'Neill, President Donald Trump's pick to lead the National Science Foundation, saying the nominee didn't have the votes and hadn't defended science from his perch inside the administration.

<cite index="24-6">O'Neill had held high-ranking posts at the Health and Human Services Department and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention under health secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.</cite> <cite index="24-7">Cassidy canceled the vote to confirm him, saying he didn't have the support to advance.</cite>

<cite index="24-8">O'Neill "did not do enough to stand up for science and against irresponsible decisions and statements" from Kennedy in those roles, Cassidy said at a meeting of his committee.</cite> <cite index="27-5">He said O'Neill's role in the firing of former CDC Director Susan Monarez "raised further concerns about the independent judgment he would bring to NSF."</cite>

<cite index="25-3">O'Neill "didn't have the votes," Cassidy told Science magazine after a brief business meeting.</cite> <cite index="26-6">Cassidy said he likes O'Neill personally, "but this time requires leadership and fortitude and standing up for what is right."</cite>

<cite index="26-1,26-3">A White House official told FedScoop the nomination had not been pulled.</cite> <cite index="27-13">If O'Neill is not confirmed by the end of the year, the White House will have to send his nomination again to the new Senate that convenes in January.</cite>

<cite index="27-8,27-9">If confirmed, O'Neill would have been the first NSF director who was not a scientist. The nomination sat stalled for months before Cassidy scheduled a vote, and he scheduled it without holding a public confirmation hearing.</cite>

<cite index="25-4">On Monday, a senior Democrat on the panel, Sen. Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin, had asked Cassidy to hold a hearing on O'Neill before taking up his nomination.</cite> <cite index="27-10,27-11">More than 100 scientific organizations also signed a letter urging the committee to hold a hearing. The Senate has not held a confirmation hearing for an NSF director since 1991.</cite>

<cite index="25-6">The prospect of NSF losing its 76-year-old status as an independent agency within the executive branch was another reason Cassidy effectively ended O'Neill's nomination, according to Science magazine's reporting.</cite>

<cite index="22-10">Cassidy said Wednesday his committee would have endorsed Heidi Overton to lead the Food and Drug Administration despite concerns about her role in the Trump administration's vaccine policy, but the White House withdrew her nomination before the vote.</cite> Both rejections landed on the same day, leaving two key science and health agencies without confirmed leaders.

<cite index="22-9">The NSF is an independent agency that funds basic research.</cite> <cite index="25-1">A vote to advance O'Neill's nomination was canceled at a Senate panel Wednesday morning, following fears among many scientists that someone widely seen as unfit for the position would lead the troubled $9 billion agency, as Science magazine reported.</cite>

<cite index="27-12">The committee did not set a new date for a vote, and it's unclear whether the administration will keep backing O'Neill or name someone else.</cite>

Sources cited:
- STAT News (https://www.statnews.com/2026/11/18/bill-cassidy-rejects-jim-oneill-lead-national-science-foundation/)
- Science magazine (https://www.science.org/content/article/senate-panel-derails-trump-s-controversial-pick-nsf-director)
- The Hill (https://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/6229707-senate-rejects-nsf-nominee-jim-oneill/)
- America News Nation (https://www.americanewsnation.com/2026/11/19/senate-panel-pulls-the-plug-on-trumps-pick-to-lead-the-national-science-foundation/)
- FedScoop / MLQ.ai roundup (https://mlq.ai/news/sen-cassidy-cancels-the-committee-vote-on-jim-oneill-trumps-nominee-to-lead-the-national-science-foundation/)

Reporting by Marcus Reyes, Senior Correspondent, for the US desk · ETL Newswire staff
Read more at the source

This release was originally distributed via ETL Newswire. Visit STAT News for the full story, related releases, and contact information.

Visit STAT News →