Published by Emerging Technologies Laboratory · via ETL Newswire
US· 

Scientists Sue NSF to Block Closure of Social Science Directorate as Senate Prepares to Confirm New Director Without Hearing

A coalition of research societies filed suit Nov. 9 in federal court in Boston to stop the National Science Foundation from shutting its social and behavioral sciences arm, as the Senate HELP Committee moves to advance Trump's NSF director pick without a public confirmation hearing.

By Marcus Reyes, Senior Correspondent · US Desk

WASHINGTON -- A coalition of scientific societies and university researchers filed suit against the National Science Foundation on Nov. 9, asking a federal judge in Boston to block the agency from closing its Directorate for Social, Behavioral and Economic Sciences, the unit that funds the bulk of federally supported basic research in those fields.

The lawsuit lands as the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee is set to vote Wednesday on the Trump administration's nominee to lead the agency, without having held a public confirmation hearing on him.

The plaintiffs are the Federation of Associations in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, known as FABBS, the Society of Experimental Social Psychology, the Social and Affective Neuroscience Society, and two Massachusetts researchers. They are represented by Democracy Forward.

The complaint, filed as FABBS et al. v. National Science Foundation et al. in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts under case number 1:26-cv-15015, alleges that NSF leadership violated the Administrative Procedure Act and the statute creating the agency. The suit says NSF announced in April it would eliminate the directorate, known as SBE, in fiscal year 2027 without consulting the National Science Board, without weighing the consequences, and without giving any official rationale.

Since that April announcement, the agency has moved steadily to hollow out the unit. New solicitations from SBE are down roughly 90 percent, and nearly all of the directorate's permanent staff have been reassigned, according to the complaint reviewed by Inside Higher Ed. NSF spokesperson Mike England told The New York Times that the directorate "has not been shut down."

The directorate distributes about $247 million a year and accounts for nearly two-thirds of all federal grant funding in social and behavioral sciences, according to NSF figures cited in reporting by Nation of Change.

Congress has pushed back on the administration's position. The report accompanying NSF's January 2026 appropriation directed NSF not to cut SBE's budget by more than 5 percent. The Senate Appropriations Committee's draft fiscal year 2027 spending bills, released Nov. 12, included language saying the committee "expects NSF to continue its support of these programs and to not take any steps to close the Directorate," according to Inside Higher Ed. NSF closed the unit anyway, the plaintiffs argue.

Scientists have had some success in court on related disputes. As reported by Science magazine, judges have previously ruled against NSF for terminating grants and attempting to dismantle the National Center for Atmospheric Research.

The confirmation fight over the agency's next director adds a parallel track to the dispute. Senate HELP Committee Chair Bill Cassidy, R-La., has set a Nov. 18 executive session vote on the nomination of James O'Neill without first holding a public confirmation hearing, a departure from standard practice that FABBS and more than 50 scientific groups have spent months urging the committee to avoid, according to a report in FABBS's own news release. In May, the American Association for the Advancement of Science and 50 other organizations asked the Senate to hold an open hearing, a call Research!America reiterated last week, Inside Higher Ed reported.

O'Neill, who previously served as Deputy Secretary of Health and Human Services and briefly as acting CDC director, would be the first person without a science or engineering background to lead NSF, according to Nature. Trump nominated him on March 2, after he left his HHS posts.

If the committee advances O'Neill's nomination, it still faces a tight lame-duck floor calendar. NSF Acting Director Brian Stone is set to leave at year's end, according to a report from the Federation of Associations in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, compounding the leadership vacuum at the agency.

No hearing date has been set in federal court on the FABBS lawsuit. NSF has not commented publicly on the litigation beyond the spokesperson's statement that SBE remains in place.

Sources cited:
- Democracy Forward press release (https://democracyforward.org/news/press-releases/scientists-sue-trump-vance-administration-after-unlawful-move-to-gut-federal-social-and-behavioral-science-research-funding/)
- FABBS lawsuit announcement (https://fabbs.org/news/2026/11/fabbs-files-lawsuit-to-save-sbe-directorate-at-nsf/)
- Inside Higher Ed, Nov. 16, 2026 (https://www.insidehighered.com/news/government/science-research-policy/2026/11/16/nsf-may-finally-get-director-will-anything)
- Periodic Update on Federal Science & Technology Developments, week of Nov. 8-14, 2026 (Substack) (https://jmwidder.substack.com/p/periodic-update-on-federal-science-64b)
- FABBS: Congress Returns for Post-Election Lame Duck Session (https://fabbs.org/news/2026/11/congress-returns-for-post-election-lame-duck-session/)
- Nation of Change, Nov. 10, 2026 (https://www.nationofchange.org/2026/11/10/scientists-sue-to-stop-nsf-from-closing-its-social-science-unit/)
- University World News, Nov. 13, 2026 (https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20261113083835216)

Reporting by Marcus Reyes, Senior Correspondent, for the US desk · ETL Newswire staff
Read more at the source

This release was originally distributed via ETL Newswire. Visit Democracy Forward press release for the full story, related releases, and contact information.

Visit Democracy Forward press release →